
The 2009 NHL Entry Draft is over. After months of wondering and analyzing which prospects the Avalanche might be available or who would make good picks we can now look at what they actually did. Earlier this week I gave my overall thoughts on the draft and what I thought they accomplished and did not accomplish. Here is my analysis of each pick with a grade, and an overall grade.
Pick #1, 3rd overall: C Matt Duchene, Brampton Battalion (OHL)
Analysis: What is NOT to like about this kid? The speedy two way center from Brampton will give the Avalanche a great 1-2 punch down the middle. In most years Duchene would have gone first overall so for the Avalanche to snatch him at #3 is great, great value. Duchene really elevated his game in the OHL playoffs notching 14 goals, and 26 points in 21 playoff games. Look for Duchene to spend one more year in Brampton before making the jump to the NHL level. On top of everything else, Duchene seems like a down to earth, great kid.
Grade: A+
Pick #2, 33rd overall: C Ryan O’Reilly, Erie Otters (OHL)
Analysis: O’Reilly desperately fills a need. A hard working, excellent defensive center and someone who knows how to win and does not like to lose. A great leader, and character player. You win Stanley Cups with these type of players. O’Reilly figures to be the future checking center on the Avalanche for years to come. The criticism of O’Reilly’s game is his skating, even though most scouts agree that it is adequate. I like the O’Reilly pick because it fills an organizational need. However, it is clear the organization passed on some prospects with higher offensive upside. O’Reilly will not be a whole lot more than a checking center who can fill in on the second line on occasion. Klingberg, Budish, Shore, Morin, Werek were all taken after this pick. But I’m okay with that, the organization needs more players of O’Reilly’s mold. They also got great value here, O’Reilly was projected as a late first round pick. O’Reilly will likely need a couple years in the minors.
Grade: B+
Pick #3, 49th overall: D Stefan Elliott, Saskatoon Blades (WHL)
Analysis: I keep repeating myself here but superb value again. Elliott was rated as the 17th best North American skater by NHL’s Central Scouting so to pick him at 49 is an absolute steal. Elliott has been described as an offensive defensemen with comparisons to Brian Rafalski. But if you listen to scouts he is a good two way defensemen who uses good positioning to break up plays. Without question his potential is as a PP QB. Elliott notched 16 goals, and 55 points in 71 WHL games last season. Elliott adds to the organizational strength of blueline prospects.
Grade: A
Pick #4, 64th overall: D Tyson Barrie, Kelowna Rockets (WHL)
Analysis: Barrie is a solid player. He helped lead his team to the WHL Championship and the Memorial Cup notching 4 goals and 18 points in 22 playoff games. Barrie possesses excellent acceleration and speed and has excellent hockey IQ. Decent pick, but I’m not a huge fan of this pick given the abundance of depth the organization has with this type of player. Barrie could be a good player but he is undersized and given the Elliott pick at 49 failing to draft a shutdown defensemen or a winger here I find disappointing. Barrie has an uphill battle with with Cumiskey, Shattenkirk, Elliot, Nigel Williams, Cameron Gaunce, and Colby Cohen all in the system. More a knock on the selection than the player here.
Grade: B-
Pick #5, 124th overall: G Kieran Millan, Boston University (Hockey East)
Analysis: Finally! The Avalanche address their biggest area of need in round five. I found this pick surprising and am still not a huge fan at this selection. Especially with Oliver Roy STILL available and the higher ranked of the two. But with the plethora of Avalanche prospects already at BU perhaps this pick isn’t that surprising. Millan did have a great year on a stacked BU team posting a 29-2-3 record with a 1.94 GAA and a .932 save percentage.
Grade: C+
Pick #6, 154th overall: G Brandon Maxwell, USDP (U-18)
Analysis: Another goaltender! Now this pick I like! Could be a steal when all is said and done. Maxwell was a standout for the US at last year's Under 18's, where they captured the bronze medal. He posted a 4-0-1 record with a .926 save percentage and a 2.21 goals against average. A pick with lots of potential but it is going to take some time. Maxwell will be playing hockey next season for the OHL’s Kitchener Rangers.
Grade: B+
Pick #7, 184th overall: D
Gus Young, Nobles (HIGH-MA)
Analysis: Really difficult to judge the picks by this point. He has good size and is apparently a decent skater. Young is headed to Yale and would appear like a long shot to make the organization but he has a lot of development ahead of him so we will just wait and see.
Grade: C
Aside from being mildly disappointed the Avalanche failed to address a couple organizational needs I was very pleased with the selections they made. I really think they did a good job, especially with the first three picks. I’ll be shocked if those three are not all promising NHL players. I would be much happier had they drafted a legit shutdown defenseman.
Overall I give them an A- minus for their weekend in Montreal.